Google, once synonymous with online search, has experienced a gradual decline in its search engine market share. For the first time since 2015, Google’s search market share fell below 90%. This dip highlights a transformative decade, driven by strengthened competition, evolving consumer expectations around privacy, frustration with ad-saturated experiences and outcomes from recent monopoly litigation.
Increased Competition: A New Era of Search
Google has long enjoyed an overwhelming market dominance, but the landscape is changing. Although Google still holds onto the lion’s share of the market, competitors and artificial intelligence are shaking things up.
Bing’s strategic integration with Copilot introduces a fresh, conversational search experience, attracting users eager for better results and experience. Additionally, niche platforms like DuckDuckGo, with its robust privacy promises, alleviate users’ tracking concerns.
The popularity of TikTok has also attracted Gen Z users to utilize the platform as a search engine. The rapid rise of a variety of AI technologies has also caused some detraction from Google’s search experience.
Consumer Privacy Concerns: Users Demand Control
Today’s consumers are more privacy-conscious than ever before. Google’s traditional model of data-driven ad personalization has increasingly come under scrutiny. Platforms prioritizing user privacy, offering transparent data practices and minimal tracking resonate strongly with most users.
Users have also expressed scrutiny due to Google’s continuous delay in allowing users to opt out of third-party cookies. Google announced that it would move toward getting rid of third-party cookies in 2020 and recently announced that it will not be moving forward with this initiative.
An Overwhelmingly Ad-Heavy Experience
Google’s ad-heavy interface, particularly on mobile, has frustrated users seeking quick and relevant results. This friction contributes significantly to users exploring less cluttered alternatives. Google’s competitors, recognizing this frustration, offer cleaner search results, which makes the user experience more enjoyable and efficient.
Monopoly Lawsuit: A Critical Turning Point
The recent landmark antitrust lawsuit filed by the Department of Justice has profound implications for Google. Accused of engaging in anti-competitive practices, Google faced allegations of limiting market entry and reducing consumer choice through exclusive deals and preferential placements. The lawsuit’s outcomes, including potential mandatory operational adjustments and increased transparency, could further erode Google’s dominance.
What’s Next
As digital marketers, adapting to this evolving landscape is crucial. With Google’s future being uncertain, starting to experiment and test other platforms for paid advertising campaigns will be critical for marketers looking to stay ahead.
Microsoft ads, TikTok and Reddit advertising platforms have started to gain popularity as alternative options to Google and may be worth considering for your brand. Additionally, it’s important to start diversifying your SEO strategy beyond Google and begin optimizing content for AI platforms by updating content and keyword strategies for longer more specific queries.
By proactively responding to Google’s shifting role, marketers can seize new opportunities to engage consumers.
Stay connected on the latest digital trends by subscribing to our Thoughts from the 313 newsletter.
Ryan Solecki is a senior paid media specialist at Franco. Connect with him on LinkedIn.
