Client
Year
Deliverables
Situation
An Ohio-based law firm was deciding whether to pay for premium placement on two national legal directories. Prospective clients now ask AI tools to recommend an attorney. The firm looked to Franco to find out whether those tools use the directories as sources and whether paying would help the firm appear in more answers.
Approach
Franco ran a focused two-week audit using AI Peekaboo. The platform tracked five AI tools as they answered questions about choosing an attorney in the firm’s practice areas, recording every source each tool cited in its answers.
Franco then examined which directory pages the AI tools relied on most and where paid listings appeared on those pages. We also compared how often the tools cited the directories with how often they cited the firm’s own website.
Results
The findings informed the firm’s decision to buy paid placement on the larger directory. AI tools cited both directories often, meaning they used them as sources in their answers. The larger directory was cited more than twice as often as the second one and more often than the firm’s own website.
Four practice area pages on the larger directory drew about 40% of its citations. When an AI tool read one of those pages, the paid listings were the first names it saw, ahead of every unpaid listing. That gives paid placements a real advantage, although the data cannot yet prove that paying leads to more mentions of the firm.
On the firm’s own website, one AI tool was quoting the home page awards language word for word. The biggest gap was in one core practice area. The directory’s page for that area was the most cited page in the audit, while the firm’s own page on it was rarely used.
Franco used those findings to shape recommendations for the firm’s new website and upcoming awards campaign. For the awards, we advised keeping the language AI tools were already quoting and featuring new awards on practice area pages. For the website, we advised giving each type of case result its own page.
The firm now knows which pages AI tools read, where paid listings appear and where its own content falls short, enabling them to invest in the larger directory with confidence and build a new website that AI tools are more likely to cite.
