Skip to main content

Key Takeaways:

  • AI platforms like ChatGPT and Claude don’t share the individual prompts people enter, which means no AI visibility tool can show the real questions behind a brand’s visibility.
  • Google Search Console now shows which pages appear in Google’s AI features, and robots.txt tests and server logs show whether AI bots can crawl a site and whether they already have.
  • ChatGPT’s new Business Hub gives businesses that claim and verify their profile 28 days of mentions, website clicks and discovery topics, though it stops short of individual prompts and competitor comparisons.
  • AI visibility tools model how a brand shows up for specific prompts at a single point in time, and repeated testing turns those results into trends that can guide communication across earned, shared and owned channels.

With AI changing how people search, it’s not surprising there has been an onslaught of AI visibility tools coming to market over the last few years. 

But like any new technology, there is still confusion and misunderstanding around what exactly these tools do. What do they actually tell us and why is it valuable to look at? 

The answer depends, and it’s easiest to start with what they can’t tell us.

They Don’t Answer: What Questions People Are Asking AI

AIO (or AEO, or GEO, depending on who you ask) is fundamentally different from traditional SEO for one important reason: Platforms like ChatGPT and Claude don’t share what users are inputting. 

In contrast, search engines like Google and Bing share anonymized details on the terms people are searching and how often. For example, if you open Google Search Console, you can see the top queries bringing people to your site, how many impressions each earned and how many clicks each one drove. These details are the cornerstone of an SEO strategy, demonstrating what audiences are looking for and where your brand is currently showing up.

Until recently, LLMs didn’t share any of that. OpenAI has since launched Businesses in ChatGPT in beta, which gives businesses that claim and verify their profile a first-party view of how ChatGPT references them. Its discovery topics group the common themes in ChatGPT answers that mentioned or cited a business. Those themes don’t reveal individual prompts, search volume or customer intent, and OpenAI says businesses don’t receive individual prompts or consumer conversations. That means there is still no tool, third-party or first-party, with access to the questions themselves.

Read more: If You Remember One Thing About AI Visibility, Make It This

Within Google Search Console, there are some clues. Google’s main Performance report doesn’t distinguish between searches that generated “regular” Google results and searches that resulted in an AI Overview. A search with a high number of impressions and a low number of clicks could be a sign that your content is showing up in an AI Overview. Previously, this would have been a red flag for traditional SEO. Now it could just mean you’re showing up in AI Overviews, which naturally have a lower click-through rate, and that can be a positive indicator of your content’s quality. 

They Don’t Answer: What Prompts Are Driving Traffic to Your Site

That same gap carries over to traffic. Because AI visibility tools don’t have access to the real conversations or questions users are having with LLMs, they aren’t able to show you what specific prompts are driving traffic to your website. 

Your web analytics can fill in part of the picture. Google Analytics and similar platforms show visits referred from AI platforms like ChatGPT or Perplexity, along with the pages those visitors landed on, though never the question that sent them there. Some of that traffic still ends up labeled as direct, which means the real number is likely higher than what gets reported. 

Within Google Search Console, you can now see which URLs on your website are showing up in Google’s AI features. Earlier this year, Google added generative AI performance reports that show your impressions within AI features on Search, such as AI Overviews and AI Mode, as well as AI features in Discover. The new reports break those impressions down by page, country, device and date, and they’ve been available to all websites since the end of August. The queries behind those impressions aren’t included, which keeps the prompts themselves out of view. 

Bing Webmaster Tools has a similar AI Performance report that shows how often your pages are cited in Microsoft Copilot and Bing’s AI-generated summaries. 

ChatGPT’s Business Hub has a similar but more limited view. Once a business is claimed and verified, admins can see mentions and website clicks from the past 28 days. However, a mention only counts when ChatGPT references the business’s website, so naming the brand alone doesn’t register. Website clicks show how often people clicked through, but they don’t confirm visits or conversions. Some metrics may also be blank because activity hasn’t reached the reporting threshold. As with Search Console, you still can’t see the prompts behind the numbers. 

They Do Answer: Whether Your Content Can Be or Has Been Crawled by AI Bots

Before an AI platform can cite your content, its bots have to be able to reach it. A crawler is still a crawler, and a page it can’t get to won’t inform the answers it helps build.

By testing your robots.txt file or using online AI crawler check tools, you can see whether AI bots are able to crawl your content. Your server access logs show whether they actually have. Most hosting providers log every request made to your website, including visits from AI bots. Known AI crawlers like GPTBot or ClaudeBot show up in the raw access logs from your host (such as WP Engine) or in your CDN’s logs and dashboards (such as Cloudflare). 

It’s also worth knowing that AI platforms run more than one bot. OpenAI’s GPTBot and Anthropic’s ClaudeBot collect content for model training, while separate bots index pages for search and fetch them when a user asks a question. Settings for each are independent, meaning a site can block training while still allowing its content to appear in AI answers. Defaults can shift, too. Cloudflare switched its default to block AI crawlers in July 2025, which makes a quick check worthwhile even for sites that have never touched their robots.txt file. 

They Do Answer: How Your Brand Is Showing Up in Specific Searches*

This comes with a huge caveat. AI visibility tools use modeled results to show you how your brand is showing up in a specific search, at a specific point in time. Various factors influence AI’s answers, and if you ask the same prompt two times in a row, you will likely get different answers. Past chat history and user preferences take this a step further. That means the statistical likelihood of the same person, much less two different people, getting the same exact answer from an AI platform multiple times is low.

However, when the same prompt is tested again and again, meaningful trends begin to appear. Over time, brands can see how often they show up compared with competitors and which sources LLMs cite when they answer. The patterns point to where visibility can improve, whether that’s a page that needs updating or a publication worth pitching. 

Business Hub doesn’t replace this kind of testing. The beta covers only ChatGPT and offers no share of voice, competitor comparison or export. AI visibility tools remain the way to see how a brand compares with competitors across platforms and which sources shape those answers. 

Read more: You're Measuring AI Visibility Wrong. Here's What Really Matters.

This is the value of integrated communications. The sources AI pulls from are rarely limited to a brand’s own website, and they often include trade coverage and community sites like Reddit. Communicating consistently across earned, shared and owned platforms helps ensure your brand’s message is showing up to audiences where it matters. A claimed ChatGPT profile adds one more owned channel, letting a business keep its description, category, logo and policies current, though OpenAI notes claiming doesn’t guarantee higher placement.

Want to understand how your brand is showing up across AI and traditional search? Get in touch.

Lexi Trimpe is the Director of Digital & AI at Franco. Connect with her on LinkedIn.